Garden City

3 Introduction

The Garden City Movement, a utopian concept in urban planning, was introduced by Ebenezer Howard in the late 19th century. The movement emphasized the importance of balancing the town and country, creating sustainable communities with ample green spaces and a focus on the environment. It aimed to provide ideal living conditions, with a balance of public buildings and individual homes, cooperative kitchens, schools, playgrounds, churches, and factories. The infrastructure was designed to take care of the health and welfare of the community. Letchworth Garden City and Welwyn Garden City in England and Radburn, NJ are some notable examples.

Objectives

  1. Learn about the Garden City Movement
  2. Understand the positive aspects and criticisms of the movement 

Lectures

Key Takeaway:

  • The Garden City Movement was a revolutionary urban planning concept developed in the early 20th century to address issues such as overcrowding, pollution, and poor living conditions in cities.
  • The motivation behind the movement was to create self-sufficient, sustainable communities that were designed to be in harmony with nature, with a focus on providing ample green space, affordable housing, and access to communal facilities.
  • The impact of the Garden City Movement can still be seen today, with many successful examples such as Letchworth Garden City and Welwyn Garden City in the UK. However, criticisms of the movement include its failure to address issues of inequality and lack of diversity, and the limited impact it has had in developing countries.

 

The Concept of Garden City Movement

In the early 20th century, the Garden City movement emerged as a response to the accelerated urbanization in Europe. The central idea behind this concept was to develop self-contained communities that had access to all necessary amenities while preserving green spaces. Ebenezer Howard, the founder of this movement, envisioned creating towns that could house a certain number of people and could expand when necessary. These communities were based on the principles of combining urban and rural life. They aimed to provide an alternative to overcrowded and polluted urban centers while offering a better quality of life.

The implementation of the Garden City movement saw the construction of environmentally friendly and economical housing, capitalizing on green spaces, encouraging public transportation, and creating job opportunities away from central urban areas. These communities aimed to be self-sufficient while promoting both communal and inter-personal interaction.

The Garden City movement proved highly influential, with many towns and cities worldwide adopting these principles. Their influence can be seen in new urban developments globally. Such developments continue to emphasize the importance of green spaces, self-sufficiency, and the well-being of citizens.

The History of Garden City Movement

The Garden City Movement has a rich and significant history. It originated from the vision of Ebenezer Howard, who in 1898, proposed a holistic approach to urban planning. This approach aimed to eliminate the problems associated with industrialization and overcrowding by creating sustainable and self-sufficient communities surrounded by greenbelts.

Following this, Howard established the Garden City Association and formed Letchworth Garden City in Hertfordshire, UK, which became the first garden city in 1903. The concept quickly spread around the world, including places such as Germany, Australia, South Africa, and India.

 

Design and Structure of Garden Cities

The Features of Garden Cities

Garden Cities are characterized by a unique blend of urban and rural features that offer sustainable living. From landscaping to transportation, the holistic approach to designing these cities aims at promoting health, well-being, and access to nature. 

  • Balance between town and country: Garden Cities were designed to be a balance between the best of town and country life. They would be surrounded by greenbelts to preserve the countryside, but they would also have a mix of residential, industrial, and agricultural land uses.
  • Mixed-use development: Garden Cities were designed to be mixed-use developments, with a variety of housing types and businesses located close together. This would help to create a sense of community and reduce the need for people to travel long distances.
  • Public ownership of land: Garden Cities were to be owned by the community, not by private developers. This would ensure that the land was used for the benefit of the community as a whole, not for the profit of a few individuals.
  • Aesthetic design: Garden Cities were to be designed with an eye to beauty and harmony. They would feature wide streets, green spaces, and attractive architecture.

A large circle with a small circle in the center that is labeled "Central City". From the center circle there are 6 lines that radiate out to smaller circles.

Image: Garden City Design

Ebenezer Howard

Ebenezer Howard was a British urban planner and social reformer who is best known for his concept of the garden city. He published his influential book “To-Morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform” in 1898, outlining his vision of planned communities that combined the advantages of urban and rural living. Howard’s ideas laid the foundation for the garden city movement, which aimed to create self-contained, balanced towns surrounded by greenbelts, promoting social harmony and a high quality of life.

Sepia toned image of a balding man with a white handlebar moustache and small oval glasses.

Howard was inspired by the utopian vision in Edward Bellamy’s 1888 sci-fi novel Looking Backward, in which the United States has transformed over time into a working socialist system. Though his plan fell far short of Bellamy’s vision, Howard imagined that the land of his Garden Cities would be cooperatively owned and rents could stay low. The most striking feature of his plan

Modal Title

The opening preface of the book “Living as we do in the closing year of the twentieth century, enjoying the blessings of a social order at once so simple and logical that it seems but the triumph of common sense, it is no doubt difficult for those whose studies have not been largely historical to realize that the present organization of society is, in its completeness, less than a century old. No historical fact is, however, better established than that till nearly the end of the nineteenth century it was the general belief that the ancient industrial system, with all its shocking social consequences, was destined to last, with possibly a little patching, to the end of time. How strange and wellnigh incredible does it seem that so prodigious a moral and material transformation as has taken place since then could have been accomplished in so brief an interval! The readiness with which men accustom themselves, as matters of course, to improvements in their condition, which, when anticipated, seemed to leave nothing more to be desired, could not be more strikingly illustrated. What reflection could be better calculated to moderate the enthusiasm of reformers who count for their reward on the lively gratitude of future ages!”

Drawing split in two. On the top is a rainy image that says "One Hundred years hence". On the bottom is a city with trolley cars, horses, and pedestrians. It says "Roofed cities fine weather insured.

Ebenezer Howard cared deeply about social justice. He believed that the way we live in our cities has a profound impact on our social and economic well-being. He saw the overcrowded, polluted, and unhealthy cities of the 19th century as a breeding ground for poverty, crime, and social unrest. He believed that we could create a more just and equitable society by building cities that were designed to promote health, happiness, and opportunity for all.

Howard’s vision of the Garden City was a utopian one, but it was also a practical one. He believed that we could create a better world by building cities that were based on the principles of social justice, environmental sustainability, and economic prosperity. His ideas have had a profound impact on the way we think about cities, and they continue to inspire people around the world who are working to create a more just and sustainable future.

  • He believed that everyone should have access to affordable housing, regardless of their income.
  • He believed that cities should be designed to promote social interaction and community building.
  • He believed that cities should be built in harmony with nature, and that they should be designed to protect the environment.
  • He believed that cities should be economically prosperous, and that they should provide opportunities for everyone to succeed.

Notable Garden Cities

Garden Cities with a notable history

Garden Cities have had a significant impact on urban planning and sustainability. These cities prioritize green spaces and aim to promote healthy living. In this section, we explore some of the prominent Garden Cities globally, including Letchworth Garden City in the UK and Radburn, New Jersey in the US.

Letchworth Garden City is widely regarded as the first Garden City, established in 1903. Its design inspired the concept of Garden Cities and paved the way for many others globally. Radburn, New Jersey, developed in the 1920s, is another noteworthy example of a Garden City. Its innovative design prioritized pedestrian pathways and minimized car usage while increasing green spaces.

In Almere, Netherlands, the creation of an entirely new Garden City started in the 1970s, with sustainable living as a key driver. Development included natural habitats and green corridors, ensuring biodiversity remained part of the city’s landscape.

 

Letchworth Garden City

This exceptional experiment town, located in Hertfordshire, is the world’s first Garden City. Letchworth emphasizes the ethos of Ebenezer Howard with social, environmental and economic values. It was built to offer affordable housing and employment opportunities outside London, providing a healthier lifestyle for its residents through proximity to nature. Today, the city has a distinct character with attractive gardens, recreational parks, a thriving arts scene and local farmers markets.

Letchworth Garden City offers numerous cultural attractions to visitors such as Broadway Cinema, The Community Museum, International Garden Cities Exhibition Centre, and etcetera. The city attracts tourists seeking an authentic experience of life in an early twentieth-century model community.

 

 

Welwyn Garden City

Welwyn Garden City‘s unique features include its separation of residential areas from industrial zones through landscaping, maintaining green corridors between neighborhoods, creating safe pedestrian paths for ease of movement, and ensuring equal access to community facilities such as schools, shops, parks, etc., which contribute significantly towards mental well-being.

Large green linear park in the center of the picture. It is surrounded by large brick buildings

A notable historical fact is that during World War II, Welwyn Garden City provided temporary accommodation to families displaced from London due to bombing raids. Eventually, these refugees became permanent residents contributing towards the city’s growth and development today.

 

Radburn, New Jersey

 Radburn, New Jersey, is a planned community that was built in the early 1920s. It was designed by Clarence Stein and Henry Wright.  It was promoted as the ‘town for the motor age’, The community was intended to be a self-sufficient entity, with residential, commercial and industrial areas each supplementing the needs of others. The basic layout of the community introduced the “super-block” concept, cul-de-sac (cluster) grouping, interior parklands, and separation of vehicular and pedestrian traffic to promote safety. Every home was planned with access to park walks. The buildings were also designed with a focus on park areas, with living and sleeping rooms facing out towards these areas.

The creation of Radburn was massively effected by the 1929 stock market crash, with only one quarter of the full design being realised. The City Housing Corporation was declared bankrupt in 1934, leaving the town incomplete causing the surrounding lands to be sold off.  It was named a National Historic Landmark in 2005.

Cover a pamphlet that says Radburn Garden Homes.  The drawing is an aerial view of a neighborhood map that is mostly green, with a center street and radial streets each with a set of homes.  Surrounding the neighborhood is a large circular park with kids playing together. It should be noted that all of the kids are white.

Lakeshore and Lake Vista, Louisiana

Lakeshore and Lake Vista are two neighborhoods in New Orleans, Louisiana that were developed in the early 20th century as part of the Garden City Movement. The neighborhoods are surrounded by Lake Pontchartrain and feature a mix of residential, commercial, and industrial uses. The neighborhoods also have a number of parks and green spaces, including the Lakeshore Nature Trail and the Lake Vista Playground.

Black and white photo of neighborhood model

 

 Baldwin Hills Village, California (now called Village Green)

 Baldwin Hills Village is a historic planned community in Los Angeles, California. It was designed by architect Clarence Stein and developed by the Baldwin Hills Development Company in the 1940s and 1950s. The community is located in the Baldwin Hills area of South Los Angeles, and it is known for its unique design, which features a mix of single-family homes, apartments, and commercial buildings.

 

 Black and white photo with large grassy area in the center surrounded by 2-4 story brick buildings.

 Baldwin Hills Village was originally conceived as a model community for the working class. Stein and his colleagues believed that the community could provide a better quality of life for working-class families by offering them access to affordable housing, green space, and a variety of amenities. The community was also designed to be self-sufficient, with its own schools, shops, and businesses. Much of their philosophical framework came from the Garden City Movement.  

Large tree with intricate root system in the foreground. In the background is a 2 story green multifamily residential building.

The Impact of Garden City Movement

The Garden City Movement had a significant impact on urban planning globally. Its goal was to create self-contained communities with ample green spaces and affordable housing. This approach was based on the idea of designing cities as socially and economically sustainable entities.

 Since its inception in the late 19th century, the Garden City Movement has influenced urban planning across the globe. Its emphasis on green spaces, walkability, and community-led planning has been adopted by city planners worldwide. Additionally, its approach to public housing has been replicated in many countries, providing affordable housing to low-income families.

One unique aspect of the Garden City Movement was its emphasis on a balanced relationship between nature and urban development. The movement also proposed new ideas on urban mobility, such as segregated pedestrian and vehicular traffic. These ideas have been widely adopted, even in modern urban planning.

 

Positive Aspects of Garden City Movement

The Garden City Movement has had a significant positive impact on urban planning. Its principles of green spaces, affordable housing, and community-focused design have inspired many modern developments worldwide. These aspects promote healthy lifestyles and social cohesion, reducing stress levels amongst residents in densely populated areas.

In addition to creating sustainable environments, the Garden City Movement prioritizes the use of public transportation systems that reduce pollution levels while improving accessibility across metropolitan areas.

One unique characteristic of the Garden City model is its emphasis on self-sufficiency through local production and consumption of goods. This idea encourages stronger community bonds and boosts local economies by fostering a closer relationship between producers and consumers. Furthermore, this approach promotes environmental sustainability by reducing reliance on global supply chains that result in higher carbon emissions.

  • Sustainability: Garden Cities are designed to be sustainable communities. They are built around a greenbelt, which helps to protect them from urban sprawl and pollution. Garden Cities also emphasize mixed-use development, which helps to reduce traffic and promote walking and biking.
  • Social equity: Garden Cities are designed to be socially equitable communities. They are built to provide affordable housing for all residents, regardless of income. Garden Cities also emphasize community engagement and social interaction, which helps to build a sense of belonging among residents.
  • Aesthetics: Garden Cities are designed to be aesthetically pleasing communities. They are built with a focus on green space, public art, and walkability. Garden Cities also emphasize the importance of natural beauty, which helps to improve the quality of life for residents.

 

Criticisms of Garden City Movement

  • Utopianism: Howard’s vision of the Garden City was often seen as utopian and unrealistic. Critics argued that it was impossible to create a perfect community, and that the Garden City would inevitably be subject to the same problems as any other city.
  • Inaccessibility: Garden Cities were often criticized for being inaccessible to people who could not afford to live there. The high cost of housing in Garden Cities made them out of reach for many people, particularly those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.
  • Environmental impact: Some critics have argued that Garden Cities have a negative environmental impact. They point to the fact that Garden Cities require a large amount of land, and that they can lead to increased traffic and pollution.
  • Social isolation: Critics have also argued that Garden Cities can lead to social isolation. They point to the fact that Garden Cities are often self-contained communities, and that they can make it difficult for people to interact with people from different backgrounds.

Conclusion

The ‘Garden City Movement’ had a significant impact on urban planning in the late 19th and early 20th century, attempting to counteract urbanization and industrialization by creating sustainable cities that valued green spaces, community, and well-being. The concept of garden cities also highlighted the importance of affordable housing and infrastructure development. The idea of creating balanced communities remains a priority in contemporary urban planning.

Notably, the ‘Garden City Movement’ is recognized as a precursor to modern urban planning. Its principles have influenced city development worldwide, including the establishment of new towns and the provision of public housing. This movement played a crucial role in shaping our modern cities and continues to be a source of inspiration and guidance for contemporary planners.

A unique aspect of the Garden City Movement was its emphasis on a holistic approach to urban design and the use of green technologies. 

The Garden City Movement was a revolutionary concept that aimed to address the negative effects of rapid urbanization and industrialization. Its influence on modern city planning has been significant and continues to shape our approach to urban design. 

 

Five Facts About the Garden City Movement:

  • ✅ The Garden City Movement was founded by Sir Ebenezer Howard in 1898. 
  • ✅ The movement aimed to create planned communities that combined the best of city and country living. 
  • ✅ The Garden City concept influenced urban planning and development around the world. 
  • ✅ Letchworth Garden City, located north of London, was the first Garden City and still exists today as a model community. 
  • ✅ The Garden City Movement emphasized the importance of green spaces, community involvement, and affordable housing. 

FAQs about Garden City Movement

What is the Garden City Movement?

The Garden City Movement began in the late 19th century as a response to urbanization and overcrowding in cities. It was a reform movement that aimed to create cities that were more humane, efficient, and beautiful by combining the best features of town and country living while also promoting social reform and community involvement.

Who founded the Garden City Movement?

The Garden City Movement was founded by Ebenezer Howard in 1898. He envisioned creating self-contained communities surrounded by greenbelts, with a balance of city and countryside amenities, and a mix of affordable housing options.

What are the principles of the Garden City Movement?

The principles of the Garden City Movement include creating self-contained communities that are surrounded by greenbelts, providing a balance of city and countryside amenities, and offering a mix of affordable housing options. The movement also emphasizes community involvement, social reform, and environmental preservation.

Are there any famous Garden Cities?

Yes, there are several famous Garden Cities around the world. Letchworth and Welwyn Garden City in England were the first two Garden Cities. Radburn, New Jersey, in the US, is another Garden City, as well as Kitakyushu, Japan, and Tapiola in Finland.

How has the Garden City Movement influenced urban planning today?

The concepts and principles of the Garden City Movement have greatly influenced modern urban planning. Many of the ideas introduced by the movement, such as greenbelts, mixed-use development, and pedestrian-friendly design, have become standard practices in urban design.

What are the benefits of living in a Garden City?

Living in a Garden City provides a sense of community and belonging. The inclusion of green spaces and mixed-use development provides access to fresh air, exercise, and amenities. The integration of social reform and community involvement also leads to a more equitable and inclusive society. Additionally, the environmental preservation initiatives encourage sustainable living.

Quick Check

How did Lewis Mumford describe the Garden City?

A place for the wealthy to retreat into nature

Answer B reply text

A suburb for the working poor

Answer reply text

An integrated foundation for an effective urban life

Response text to display when this answer is selected.

A solution for urban challenges

Answer reply text

Check Answer

 

 

 

Leave a Comment